I find this very interesting. I have an isy 994i already with an Insteon PLM module. I've tried a bunch of Android smartphone apps and none of them really worked well, so I have to use the Mobilinc one with the portal so it's like $30/year. I'm debating about adding z-wave (or z-wave plus or whatever), and now I'm wondering if the mi casa verde stuff would be "better" in terms of UI/smartphone app.
My roomate bought a smartthings for his dad, but by the time they figured out it wouldn't work out for him, it was too late to return, so now there's a smartthings hub at home as well.
The insteon hub pro looks like it has some major issues (oh, did i mention I Have some insteon water sensors?)
I'm sure the isy is "powerful", but it took me like a whole day to get the darn water sensor to even semi-work by hunting around here to find a myriad of scripts (had a power outage a few weeks ago and now I'm not so sure the water sensor is in the right "mode" now).
Not terribly keen on the $30/year for smartphone support (but the mobilinc app is the "nicest" I've seen other than the actual insteon hub software, but the hub apparently doesn't work with the water sensors and the reviews aren't all that great).
The pricing between z-wave and insteon seems about the same (ie, $40-45 for say, a light switch that's wired into the wall for both protocols), so I wouldn't say either one is really "cheaper". I usually buy from smarthome although I think home depot (or is it Lowes?) sells some z-wave stuff.
I guess I'm at a crossroads and not sure what to do.
Ideally:
I'd like a hub/thingy that worked with Insteon and z-wave WITH a better software UI and smartphone app that didn't run me $30/year and lots of time to setup. I don't really have anything fancy other than:
turn this on at X time, and alert me when water is spraying everywhere.
Originally I went with the isy because I did not want to have a computer powered up 24/7 with a serial cable/usb cable to the insteon "hub/whatever" to use the fancy software.
However, I've since setup a VMware server and run some VM's (mostly linux), so if absolutely necessary I could use some other software to do the more "easy" setup/programming --if such a beast exists.
Anyway thanks for letting me blab.
--Kevin