Hi. Sorry that you're having issues. Here's a crazy question. Have you reinstalled the original thermostat (or a basic non Insteon thermostat) to the same terminals to establish/deduction if the 2441TH thermostat is out to lunch? If you don't have another thermostat, you can check out the YouTube video below. I'm not sure exactly where things stand on your end so here goes. Like the guy in the video says, you can even do it at the thermostat... This should tell you if your 2441TH has some sort of fault. I own 4 of that exact model and I have never had crazy issues like what you're up against. I don't recall reading if your furnace actually works which is why I'm posting this. Sorry if this might have nothing to do with the price of eggs. (Your connections to the 2441TH look fine from what I see. As for the image with the Cool 30 and Heat 20 both showing at the same time on the display - that's some funky stuff). I also would make sure that I don't have a Program sending conflicting info to the thermostat. Also, I googled this for you (I have never had to do this mind you):
To change the temperature on an Insteon thermostat to Fahrenheit, you can calibrate the thermostat as follows:
Press and hold the Program button until the display goes blank
• Tap Time/Sensor to enter Temperature Calibration Mode
• Tap Mode to cycle between temperature and humidity calibration
• Use the Up or Down arrows to adjust the temperature until it matches the calibrated source
Last but not least, in EISY you will get 3 things...
Thermostat Main
Thermostat Cool Ctl
Thermostat Heat Ctl