dth122 Posted November 8, 2014 Posted November 8, 2014 I'm having problems linking a new Switchinlinc Dimmer 2477D (rev 7.6) to my system. It's the only Insteon device I have at the moment. Everything else is X10. All X10 devices are working well. The problem is that when I try to link I get "Unable to determine Insteon engine". I've tried entering the address manually (with and without selecting the device type), and using the Start Linking feature. None of those seem to work. I have a 994i/IR PRO v4.0.5 and a 2413S. Any ideas as to what could be wrong? The 2477D is a replacement for an old X10 switch which was working fine, but I wanted to replace it with a dimmer. I figured the move to Insteon would be an upgrade but so far it doesn't seem like it. - Dave
LeeG Posted November 8, 2014 Posted November 8, 2014 That message means the PLM cannot talk to the 2477D. With the 2477D being the only Insteon device the 2 120 v legs are likely not coupled so the PLM could be on one leg and the 2477D on the other.
EricK Posted November 8, 2014 Posted November 8, 2014 How far from the plm is the switchlinc. When we moved into our house 4 years ago there were more than 50 x10 devices. After the bedroom lights turned on a few times in the middle of the night I started my upgrade migration. Hang in there Dave and you will get this worked out. Probably need some more insteon gear to strengthen your system. I have an outlet box with an extension cord that I can put a switch into and plug in. This way I can bench test all new devices before I install them.
dth122 Posted November 8, 2014 Author Posted November 8, 2014 I have one of the Leviton X10 phase coupler/repeaters. Would that couple the phases for Insteon devices as well?
oberkc Posted November 8, 2014 Posted November 8, 2014 If it is an active repeater, probably not. If passive, probably yes.
dth122 Posted November 9, 2014 Author Posted November 9, 2014 I just tried turning on the dryer and oven (both electric) and neither seemed to improve the situation. So I'm not sure it's a phase coupling issue. The new dimmer is in the garage and probably 50-60ft (straight run) from the breaker panel, and quote some distance from the PLM, which is upstairs at the other end of the house. I don't really need any more Insteon devices right now, but I guess I could put one somewhere in the middle on the first floor just to test. Is one additional device likely to fix my issue? If not, I'll just get an X10 dimmer instead.
stusviews Posted November 9, 2014 Posted November 9, 2014 An active coupler, and a repeater is active, can interfere with the INSTEON signal. (Not all do.) What is the result if you remove the coupler and turn on a 220/240V appliance?
dth122 Posted November 10, 2014 Author Posted November 10, 2014 Still didn't work with the coupler/repeater removed and oven on. I swapped out the 2477D for a Leviton X10 dimmer and now everything is working well. (within the capabilites of X10) I think I'll skip Insteon for now. - Dave
oberkc Posted November 10, 2014 Posted November 10, 2014 (edited) The oven being on is not conclusive, unfortunately. It was a good thought, however. (especially true if your oven is not electric) My suspicion remains a lack of insteon communication across electrical "phases". How many insteon devices do you have, and how many are dual-band? Is your PLM dual-band? How new is your 2477D switch? You may want also to update your ISY software to the latest version. Perhaps the switch is too new for your current software to recognize. Edited November 10, 2014 by oberkc
Brian H Posted November 10, 2014 Posted November 10, 2014 (edited) If your Leviton Coupler/Repeater is a HCA02 or 6201. It is possible it is seeing the end of an Insteon message and sending out a bogus X10 power line signal. Corrupting the Insteon command to the 2477D. They also do not send an Insteon power line signal back on the homes other phase. With the 2477D being the only Insteon device you have installed. It is very possible the power line and RF Insteon commands are not reaching it. Since the problem didn't seem to change with the Leviton Off and the electrical appliances possibly bridging the incoming Lines. Edited November 10, 2014 by Brian H
larryllix Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 Still didn't work with the coupler/repeater removed and oven on. I swapped out the 2477D for a Leviton X10 dimmer and now everything is working well. (within the capabilites of X10) I think I'll skip Insteon for now. - Dave Are you trying to communicate with this switch using X10 commands or Insteon commands?
dth122 Posted November 11, 2014 Author Posted November 11, 2014 (edited) Are you trying to communicate with this switch using X10 commands or Insteon commands? Insteon If your Leviton Coupler/Repeater is a HCA02 or 6201. It is possible it is seeing the end of an Insteon message and sending out a bogus X10 power line signal. Corrupting the Insteon command to the 2477D. They also do not send an Insteon power line signal back on the homes other phase. With the 2477D being the only Insteon device you have installed. It is very possible the power line and RF Insteon commands are not reaching it. Since the problem didn't seem to change with the Leviton Off and the electrical appliances possibly bridging the incoming Lines. It's a HCA02. I tried removing it from the system completely but it didn't fix the problem. I agree that the problem is most likely lack of signal reception. That being said, it's not worth it for me to add a bunch of Insteon devices just to communicate with one dimmer. Switching to X10 is a much cheaper and easier solution. The oven being on is not conclusive, unfortunately. It was a good thought, however. (especially true if your oven is not electric) My suspicion remains a lack of insteon communication across electrical "phases". How many insteon devices do you have, and how many are dual-band? Is your PLM dual-band? How new is your 2477D switch? You may want also to update your ISY software to the latest version. Perhaps the switch is too new for your current software to recognize. Of course it's an electric oven. Otherwise it wouldn't be relevant. I tried the dryer too with the same result. But I agree, these tests are not conclusive to rule out the phase issue. As I mentioned above... this is my only Insteon device besides the PLM, which is a 2413S. It's pretty far from the 2477D, so I don't think RF would reach it. The 2477D is brand new. I don't know if rev 7.6 is the latest, but I just got it from Smarthome so it should be. ISY software and firmware are the latest. Edited November 11, 2014 by dth122
larryllix Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 (edited) Did you do a factory reset on the SwitchLinc before linking to the ISY? I don't know how they set these devices but mine have almost all done really strange things if I didn't factory reset every new device. - remove the device completely from ISY - factory reset the SwitchLinc. Most units do this by pulling the tab out for about 10-15 seconds and then pushing it in holding it in until it stops buzzing. This usually takes a tool to poke it deep enough andnotpause at the operating / normal position.. Release and it should turn the light on. - relink it to the ISY using the address of the unit. xx.xx.xx -if the device shows up in the ISY devicetreetry to operate the controls on it's page. Let us know. Edited November 11, 2014 by larryllix
stusviews Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 Any electrical device that's 220/240V powered will adequately bridge the opposite legs of the split, single-phase electric supply. But that doesn't rule out other problems, including communication problems. What is the load? What is the result if you disconnect the load wire?
Brian H Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 The sales page doesn't mention adding an X10 address to the 2477D but the full users manual still shows how to do it. You may want to try adding an X10 address to the 2477D and see if the X10 signal can activate it.
oberkc Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 ISY software and firmware are the latest. Latest version is 4.18. I thought you had v4.0.5?
Brian H Posted November 11, 2014 Posted November 11, 2014 4.2.18 is the latest Release Candidate. 4.0.5 is the last Official Released firmware.
dth122 Posted November 12, 2014 Author Posted November 12, 2014 Sorry to disappoint everyone, but the Leviton X10 dimmer is in and working fine. It's not worth the time and effort fooling around to get one Insteon device working. Thanks for the help. - Dave
Brian H Posted November 12, 2014 Posted November 12, 2014 Sounds like you found the best solution for your problem. The Leviton probably has AGC and will work better for you. Than one lone Insteon Device.
larryllix Posted November 12, 2014 Posted November 12, 2014 I would have just programmed the SwitchLinc to work with the X10 commands until I got more Insteon devices to support the mesh-network they thrive on so well.
Recommended Posts