SHM Posted February 9, 2022 Share Posted February 9, 2022 My ISY sends Pushover a notification that my garage door has closed. For some reason, I am now getting 3 Pushover notifications for each closure. Pushover suggest that their API is getting 3 messages. Any thoughts? Link to comment
MrBill Posted February 10, 2022 Share Posted February 10, 2022 23 minutes ago, SHM said: My ISY sends Pushover a notification that my garage door has closed. For some reason, I am now getting 3 Pushover notifications for each closure. Pushover suggest that their API is getting 3 messages. Any thoughts? Post your program. Right click the program name, pick copy to clipboard (the last item) and paste it into a reply below. No way to know without seeing how the program is written. Link to comment
SHM Posted February 10, 2022 Author Share Posted February 10, 2022 The program goes like this: If SHM_Geofence =0 AND SHM_Tahoe =1 AND 'vashon2/ east door' state is open THEN SET vashon2/ east door' close Resource 'vashon east door' A jpeg of the network resource is attached Link to comment
MrBill Posted February 10, 2022 Share Posted February 10, 2022 38 minutes ago, SHM said: 'vashon2/ east door' state is open What kind of sensor is that? several random thoughts: 1) One thing that would probably work is remove "Resource 'vashon east door' " from that program and create a second program: If 'vashon2/ east door' state is close THEN Resource 'vashon east door' 2) I think the if statement is likely triggering multiple times... to find out create a create a temp integer variable... something like $iCount and add $iCount += 1 to the then body of the program you have. 3) the garage door takes time to close. therefor it's status is still open while it's closing allowing the "retrips" in #2 another way to solve this is to only allow the trip to occur once... you could do that with and integer (not state in this case) variable. If SHM_Geofence =0 AND SHM_Tahoe =1 AND 'vashon2/ east door' state is open AND $iClosingFlag = 0 THEN $iClosingFlag = 1 SET vashon2/ east door' close -- then in that second program from #1 If 'vashon2/ east door' state is close THEN Resource 'vashon east door' $iClosingFlag = 0 which will prevent the IF from being retriggered while it's closing. Link to comment
SHM Posted February 10, 2022 Author Share Posted February 10, 2022 I'll give that a try. My goal was to use Pushover to send a message to my phone telling me that the garage door successfully closed after leaving the geofence Link to comment
SHM Posted February 10, 2022 Author Share Posted February 10, 2022 By the way, the MYQ node server on Polisy has a door "state" option, so I went with that Link to comment
MrBill Posted February 10, 2022 Share Posted February 10, 2022 12 minutes ago, SHM said: I'll give that a try. My goal was to use Pushover to send a message to my phone telling me that the garage door successfully closed after leaving the geofence I do alot of that except my notification are all triggered off a variable called $sAway that is generally set by geofence but has actually 5 possible values: -1 = Away mode off, Geofence Off 0 = Away Mode Off, geofence active 1 = Away Mode On, geofence active 2 = Away mode On, Geofence off 3 = Vacation Mode (Away on, geofence off, extra lighting controls enabled) Normally that variable bounces back and forth between 0 and 1 based on geofence... the other modes are manually set via Home Assistant buttons that I created. However I don't send notifications for things that are normal, Instead I send notifications for things that are not normal, like "the upstairs fireplace is still on".. if it's off I don't need to be told that... For doors I have a string of daisy chained programs, which send a notification if a door is not closed and a total count of doors if it finds some open. (note: all but the first program are disabled and are only run by the daisy chain). for example: =================================================================================== Door Check - [ID 015C][Parent 0034] Folder Conditions for 'Door Check' If - No Conditions - (To add one, press 'Schedule' or 'Condition') Then Allow the programs in this folder to run. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc00._trigger.0 - [ID 015D][Parent 015C] If $sAway.HA is 1 Then $iDoorCheck.tally = 0 Run Program 'dc00._trigger.1' (Then Path) Else - No Actions - (To add one, press 'Action') ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc00._trigger.1 - [ID 0160][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If - No Conditions - (To add one, press 'Schedule' or 'Condition') Then Disable Program 'dc00._trigger.0' Run Program 'dc01.FrontDr' (If) Else - No Actions - (To add one, press 'Action') ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc01.FrontDr - [ID 0150][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If 'Door Switches / Front Door' Status is On Then Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc.FrontDoor' $iDoorCheck.tally += 1 Wait 2 seconds Run Program 'dc02.GarageToHouse' (If) Else Run Program 'dc02.GarageToHouse' (If) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc02.GarageToHouse - [ID 0153][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If 'Door Switches / Garage to House Door 2' Status is On Then Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc.Garage2House' $iDoorCheck.tally += 1 Wait 2 seconds Run Program 'dc03.GarageSouthOHD' (If) Else Run Program 'dc03.GarageSouthOHD' (If) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc03.GarageSouthOHD - [ID 0152][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If 'Door Switches / Garage-South OHD' Status is On Then Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc.GarageSouthOHD' $iDoorCheck.tally += 1 Wait 2 seconds Run Program 'dc04.GarageNorthOHD' (If) Else Run Program 'dc04.GarageNorthOHD' (If) --------- [Redacted a bunch of steps... all the programs follow the same format as those shown above] ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc16._tally0 - [ID 015E][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If $iDoorCheck.tally is 0 Then Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Magic Wait 2 seconds Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc._TallyZero' Wait 10 seconds Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Door Open Enable Program 'dc00._trigger.0' Else Run Program 'dc16._tally1' (If) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- dc16._tally1 - [ID 015F][Parent 015C][Not Enabled] If $iDoorCheck.tally is 1 Then Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Chime Wait 2 seconds Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc._TallyOne' Wait 10 seconds Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Door Open Enable Program 'dc00._trigger.0' Else Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Chime Wait 2 seconds Resource 'NotificationNS.doordc._ShowTally' Wait 10 seconds Set '{hide}Node Servers / Notification Controller / Service Pushover doordc' Sound Door Open Enable Program 'dc00._trigger.0' Link to comment
drprm1 Posted February 10, 2022 Share Posted February 10, 2022 I too noticed multiple Pushover messages for one event. Placed a 5 second wait before calling the NR. Working so far… Link to comment
SHM Posted February 13, 2022 Author Share Posted February 13, 2022 Your suggested program works great. I should have anticipated the garage door closing delay. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.