Getting extra notifications

[87squirrels]

I recently upgrade my 99i to a 994 and added a custom notification to one of my programs.

 

It works great, but I'm getting notifications I don't expect.

 

If
       $POND_OVERRIDE > 0
    Or (
            $POND_OVERRIDE is 0
        And (
                 (
                      $OUTDOOR_TEMP > 50
                  And $OUTDOOR_TEMP > $POND_TEMP
                 )
              Or (
                      $OUTDOOR_TEMP > 52
                  And Status  'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is 100%
                 )
              Or (
                      $POND_TEMP >= 68
                 )
            )
       )

Then
       Set 'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' 100%
       $POND_TEMP Init To $POND_TEMP
       $OUTDOOR_TEMP Init To $OUTDOOR_TEMP
       Send Notification to 'Tom' content 'Pond'

Else
       Set 'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' Off
       $POND_TEMP Init To $POND_TEMP
       $OUTDOOR_TEMP Init To $OUTDOOR_TEMP
       Send Notification to 'Tom' content 'Pond'

The OR clause is to keep from switching on and off when close to the temperature threshold.   If already running, don't shut off until it goes below the lower threshold.
POND_OVERRIDE:  <0 = off; 0 = auto; >0 = on

 

I'm receiving notifications (always "On") at random intervals. Is this somehow happening when one of the state variables changes, even though it's already on? I see that the latest notification (arrived at 12:08) matches the last update time of the OUTDOOR_TEMP variable.

 

Pond status update:  ${sys.node.14 81 9 1.ST}

${alert.details}
--------------------------------
Pond status update: On

    At: 2014/05/16 12:08:54 PM
Program: Pond - winter pump
 Value: 2.1

[LeeG]

A change to the State variable value causes the Program to trigger. As OUTDOOR_TEMP goes from 52 to 53, 53 to 54, 54 to 55, etc the Then clause executes

 

Or (

$OUTDOOR_TEMP > 52

And Status 'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is 100%

)

[larryllix]

You have all that complex condition logic in an enabled programme. Every time the status of one/any of the parameters changes you will get a notification from the "Then" or the "Else

 

Each and every time any parameter you are checking changes the whole logic statement will be tested for true or false and the appropriate Then or Else will run.

 

Break the programme into two statements with the first triggering events and the second full of conditions that you do not want to trigger events AND DISABLED.

 

For instance; It appears you would not want a notification every time the pond temperature or outside temperature changes one degree up or down. With the programme enabled these will be trigger events that will evaluate the whole complex logic test and execute True or False, based on that outcome. Turning your pump on when it is already on is never noticed but the notification will be.

[Xathros]

I am assuming that the variables are State variables. If that is the case, anytime a state variable's value changes, any If statements that reference it will be triggered and evaluated true (then) or false (else). In this case, since you have a notification in both the then and else sections, you will get notified anytime the temp changes.

 

I think you need to remove:

 And Status  'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is 100%

It's pointless.

 

Remove the notifications from this program altogether. Create a second program to notify on status change of the pump:

 

If 
   Status  'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is 100%
   Or Status  'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is Off

Then
  Send Notification to 'Tom' content 'Pond'

Else

 

Hope this helps.

 

-Xathros

[87squirrels]

Thanks, I'll move the notification into a separate program, as suggested. I didn't realize (and wouldn't have noticed, until now), that the Then clause would be executed again each time one of the test conditions changes.

 

Xanthros,

 

The

And Status  'Outdoors / Pond - winter pump' is 100%

clause is there to keep the pump from switching on and off if the temperatures are close to each other. Once it's on, it will stay on as long as OUTDOOR_TEMP is above 52, even if OUTDOOR_TEMP falls below POND_TEMP.

[Xathros]

Sorry, missed that.

 

-Xathros