brians Posted December 30, 2022 Share Posted December 30, 2022 I have a few ZWave dimmers... a couple Z-Link ZL-PD100 and a Leviton DZPD3-2BW. I also have Homebridge ISY setup on a RPi. I noticed that the Z-Wave dimmers above do not seem to report their info correctly to UD Mobile or HomeBridge. They work fine in AC but I noticed I could not add a slider widget in UD Moble: In UD Mobile, I am unable to see the pencil/edit icon in top right where it should be to link the On button... I honestly did not try this with Zooz ZWave dongle before so I am not sure. I have same issue with Leviton DZPD3-2BW with the icon missing as below picture. Interesting though that a similar Leviton device that is a non-dimmable on/off plug shows that pencil icon and it is same family device just that it is a switch instead of a dimmer... Again, I just noticed that these dimmers do not show up at all in HomeKit/HomeBridge but I am pretty sure that they did before with Zooz ZWave dongle, so this starts to make me wonder. Other Z-Wave devices show up like wall switches (I don't have any wall dimmers though to test). There seems to be an is issue with ZMatter not recognizing these Z-Wave plugin dimmers correctly. Here is pic of the dimmers I am referring to that have this issue... Here is Z-Wave X-Ray Device/Channel Database Object report for Z-Link Dimmer... Z-Wave Database for uid=3.0 (0x03.00) Isy Primary Node: id=43 addr=[ZY003_1] ZW-Type: 4.17.1 (0x04.0x11.0x01) Mfg Specific: mid=789 tid=18244 pid=12338 ZWave+ RoleType=0 NodeType=0 Flags: initialized=T agi=F alwaysAwake=F Security: No Security --- 16 Command Classes --- 32 x20 V1 I S BASIC 38 x26 V4 I S SWITCH_MULTILEVEL 43 x2b V1 I S SCENE_ACTIVATION 44 x2c V1 I S SCENE_ACTUATOR_CONF 85 x55 V2 I S TRANSPORT_SERVICE 89 x59 V1 I S ASSOCIATION_GROUP_INFO 90 x5a V1 I S DEVICE_RESET_LOCALLY 94 x5e V2 I S ZWAVEPLUS_INFO 108 x6c V1 I S SUPERVISION 112 x70 V3 I S CONFIGURATION 114 x72 V2 I S MANUFACTURER_SPECIFIC 115 x73 V1 I S POWERLEVEL 122 x7a V4 I S FIRMWARE_UPDATE_MD 133 x85 V2 I S ASSOCIATION 134 x86 V3 I S VERSION 159 x9f V1 I S SECURITY_2 --- 1 AGI --- grp= 1 cc=0x5A.01 profile=0x00.01 maxRsp=1 /1 DEVICE_RESET_LOCALLY --- Status Map (1 records) --- [ 0] 0x26/SWITCH_MULTILEVEL recId=1 sgid=119 ST uom=51 prec=0 namemap=27 | min=0 max=101 --- Control Map (0 records) --- --- Responder Map (10 records) --- [ 0] sgid=119 ASSOC ASSOC (1, 1) [ 1] sgid=119 ASSOC ASSOC_MC (1, 51) [ 2] sgid=119 BASIC BASIC (2, 2) [ 3] sgid=119 BASIC BASIC_MC (2, 52) [ 4] sgid=147 BSW BSW (3, 3) [ 5] sgid=147 BSW BSW_MC (3, 53) [ 6] sgid=119 MLSW MLSW (4, 4) [ 7] sgid=119 MLSW MLSW_MC (4, 54) [ 8] sgid=259 SCENE SCENE_RSP (5, 6) [ 9] sgid=259 SCENE SCENE_RSP_MC (5, 56) --- Status Callbacks --- [ 0] 0x26/SWITCH_MULTILEVEL id=0 path="level" --- Control Callbacks --- Link to comment
Javi Posted December 30, 2022 Share Posted December 30, 2022 1 hour ago, brians said: I have a few ZWave dimmers... a couple Z-Link ZL-PD100 and a Leviton DZPD3-2BW. I also have Homebridge ISY setup on a RPi. I noticed that the Z-Wave dimmers above do not seem to report their info correctly to UD Mobile or HomeBridge. They work fine in AC but I noticed I could not add a slider widget in UD Moble: In UD Mobile, I am unable to see the pencil/edit icon in top right where it should be to link the On button... I honestly did not try this with Zooz ZWave dongle before so I am not sure. I have same issue with Leviton DZPD3-2BW with the icon missing as below picture. Hi @brians, The app currently does not support sliders for commands which require* multiple parameters. This was also true with Zooz and 500 series. The sliders are a recent addition and the same was reported but I have not had time to make a fix. As for not updating, it looks as if the app has an off "0%" status. Is this not updating when the device changes status? *require: I think both parameters are optional not required, so it should be possible. Just need some time. Link to comment
brians Posted December 30, 2022 Author Share Posted December 30, 2022 (edited) 1 hour ago, Javi said: Hi @brians, The app currently does not support sliders for commands which require* multiple parameters. This was also true with Zooz and 500 series. The sliders are a recent addition and the same was reported but I have not had time to make a fix. As for not updating, it looks as if the app has an off "0%" status. Is this not updating when the device changes status? *require: I think both parameters are optional not required, so it should be possible. Just need some time. Ok thanks, it seems that HB/HK is a different unrelated issue, I am sure dimmers worked before and were detected in HK so probably just something with ZMatter in way it reports what a switch is. I am running an ancient version of ISY HK plugin, maybe will toubleshoot more (was able to make it show up for now at least by adding the scene - I don't include all scenes in HK). I note now that in UD Mobile it shows the word parameters and I confirm that it updates to correct percentage when I adjust from AC and I can even enter a percentage in that parameter in UD Mobile and turns on light to that level, which also seems to set the default on level for this device. Below is same device in AC and I can enter a % (or previous value) and press the On button at top which will set the light's default to that percentage, but also turns the light on to that level. It correlates with UD Mobile parameters (actually there are dots in UD Mobile for the rest of them eg. Fade Up) now that I compare them. However, there does not seem to be a way for this switch to set the default on level without having it first turn on to this level. Then subsequent off/on commands will turn it on to that level. I think the issue with making a slider, if possible to do, it would affect the next default on level to whatever the slider was last set at. My takeaway from all this is Zwave dimmers kinda suck! At least with ISY Scenes, are able to set the responder level using a Command, but the light still remembers its last value. Edited December 30, 2022 by brians Link to comment
Javi Posted December 31, 2022 Share Posted December 31, 2022 1 hour ago, brians said: However, there does not seem to be a way for this switch to set the default on level without having it first turn on to this level. Then subsequent off/on commands will turn it on to that level. I think the issue with making a slider, if possible to do, it would affect the next default on level to whatever the slider was last set at. My takeaway from all this is Zwave dimmers kinda suck! At least with ISY Scenes, are able to set the responder level using a Command, but the light still remembers its last value. I think it's possible to separate, or optionally select a single parameter of the 2 parameters, just a complex UI issue. I ordered one of the same device to test. This could also allow scenes to set a single parameter. We have a backlog of features so it may be a month or so, but It appears very possible. Link to comment
brians Posted January 3, 2023 Author Share Posted January 3, 2023 (edited) My interim solution was to purchase a couple dual band Insteon Lamplinc dimmers off eBay, and put aside these Z-Wave dimmers for now Edited January 3, 2023 by brians Link to comment
brians Posted January 14, 2023 Author Share Posted January 14, 2023 (edited) An update... I tried out the Node Server "Virtual" I made a virtual switch, and a virtual dimmer. In UD Mobile it is able to add a slider widget for the virtual dimmer. I then use a varible to hold dim state and have a few programs that link it all together. Haven't really tested for race conditions yet but seems to work ok so far but I don't really think this is the best solution really. Edited January 14, 2023 by brians Link to comment
Recommended Posts