dpmenzer Posted August 29 Posted August 29 I'm getting a little frustrated with Eisy's slow evolution, and the "Smart" light bulb market. I've had Insteon light bulbs, no longer produced, iNovelli z-wave light bulbs, no longer produced, and recently had to get some additional replacements. As far as I can tell, no currently marketed bulbs are Eisy compatible. Supported formats are Bluetooth, Zigbee, Hue, Alexa, Apple and a bunch of odd balll Chinese brands. What am I missing? Dave
larryllix Posted August 29 Posted August 29 WiFi bulbs are around, and getting very commonly available, and cheap. EISY can control them natively without any further hardware. No hub, and no bridge with limited distances. They are fast and dimmable to 1% without flicker. There are many brands. I have been using MagicHome RGBCW/WW bulbs and CW/WW lamps for many years. I only have two Insteon lamps in usage now. At one time I had many Insteon controlled bulbs (never the bulbs themselves, but Insteon plug-in dimmers and wall switches.) Wifi will still be around when most of are dead.
lilyoyo1 Posted August 29 Posted August 29 7 hours ago, dpmenzer said: I'm getting a little frustrated with Eisy's slow evolution, and the "Smart" light bulb market. I've had Insteon light bulbs, no longer produced, iNovelli z-wave light bulbs, no longer produced, and recently had to get some additional replacements. As far as I can tell, no currently marketed bulbs are Eisy compatible. Supported formats are Bluetooth, Zigbee, Hue, Alexa, Apple and a bunch of odd balll Chinese brands. What am I missing? Dave Many folks on here talk about and use hue. I used to use hue when I used my polisy. I believe it works natively with it now
dpmenzer Posted August 29 Author Posted August 29 Thanks guys for the responses. Interesting on the wifi bulbs, I've looked thru the documentation but couldn't see how to talk to a wifi bulb, and did not see a polyglot that would do that either. Can you point me to an example or docs on how to talk to a wifi device/bulb? 1
Geddy Posted August 29 Posted August 29 7 hours ago, dpmenzer said: Can you point me to an example or docs on how to talk to a wifi device/bulb? I think @larryllix has some code he wrote for his own use, but think others get wifi bulbs connected to the IoX system via network resources. I'm not sure how that happens so can't point you much further than that. Try a Google Site Search for the forums to find some archived posts about wifi bulbs. There was a post by @Javi that if you have the ZMatter dongle for the eisy you can directly connect Hue bulbs to the eisy. I'm happy with the hub bulbs trough their hub and using the Hue plugin to have them in the IoX system.
larryllix Posted August 29 Posted August 29 (edited) 13 hours ago, Geddy said: I think @larryllix has some code he wrote for his own use, but think others get wifi bulbs connected to the IoX system via network resources. I'm not sure how that happens so can't point you much further than that. Try a Google Site Search for the forums to find some archived posts about wifi bulbs. There was a post by @Javi that if you have the ZMatter dongle for the eisy you can directly connect Hue bulbs to the eisy. I'm happy with the hub bulbs trough their hub and using the Hue plugin to have them in the IoX system. On that note: This depends on how tech savvy you are. Bulbs must have predefined IP addresses fixed inside your router's DHCP table. 15 variables need to be named for this usage. 4 for bulb parameters and 10 for a bulb list to be operated. 3-4 Network resources need to be defined. On/Off/SetLevels/Effects My software needs to be installed/copied in a folder on your Polisy/Eisy/ or RPi A line must be installed in the bootup system to make it run on boot-up A python file must be edited to match and define your IP addresses on machine above ISY programs need set up R, G, B, CW, and WW variables, and up to 10 bulb IDs wanted to be controlled for each command in programs. Bulb scenes are created on demand in programs and not preset. A NR needs to be called to initiate the command. Up to 10 bulbs will respond to the setting sent. Hardly any popcorn effect can be noticed with total time about 0.5 seconds for 10 bulbs. Many effects are built into most bulbs, including coloured flashing etc. No ISY looping required. Edited August 30 by larryllix 1
dpmenzer Posted August 30 Author Posted August 30 Thanks guys for the responses. Interesting on the wifi bulbs, I've looked thru the documentation but couldn't see how to talk to a wifi bulb, and did not see a polyglot that would do that either. Can you point me to an example or docs on how to talk to a wifi device/bulb? Thanks again guys. @larryllix, I'm an electrical engineer, but high frequency, radar, solid state amps. Networking, I only get wet. I understand enough about your post that I know that is not the way I want to go. I applaud your ability to get it working. When Eisy internallizes that, I would be interested. It does seem strange at this point in time to have to do all of that to send IP commands. Since I don't have an api, and don't trust these guys to be consistent, and I have enough frustration in life, that I will pursue a zigbee solution. I was hoping to avoid adding yet another protocol, but so be it. Thanks, Dave 1
mjrush Posted August 30 Posted August 30 I have some tp-link Kasa KL125 WiFi bulbs and I use the Kasa plugin to talk to them. I tried the MagicHome plugin but the bulbs I tried didn't work very well.
Recommended Posts