xlurkr

Louder than all get out though. -Tom

MMDV (My Mileage Does Vary?) My wife LOVES the voice commands. I prefer buttons, esp. when they do more than one thing (like pause DVR = turn light on dim, play = turn lights off). I think it's still hard to get the voice assistants to do multiple actions like this, but honestly I haven't looked into it a lot. And, like many, I prefer cloud independence. -Tom

No, I haven't, and I haven't made changes to the MSC programming in years. I still have the XP laptop and software, so I should be able to, but who knows when it will fail to run one day. I got lucky and was able to download and install the Total Control software before they locked it down, and I've been using those remotes and controllers ever since. I'm note sure whose fully programmable remotes and controllers a DIYer could start with or move to today. If RemoteCentral is still active, maybe you could find out over there. -Tom

I've used MX-980 remotes mostly, with some KP-900s. The KPs eat batteries fast, so I only have a few in key places to pause the DVR and mute and adjust the audio as needed, and leave the backlighting off. -Tom

I realize this might be a bit confusing. The MSC400 can be programmed to send any RS232 message you want, based on what remote key is pressed, to the serial port of the computer running CQC. It has been trained to listen for it, and issues whatever commands you define in response to receiving the right message. That can be by manipulating devices known to its ISY driver, or by REST commands to the ISY. The latter case is needed to invoke scenes on the ISY, if I remember correctly, because the driver is not scene-aware, only device-aware. Because this setup uses an RF remote, and a wired connection to CQC, it's directionless, relatively long-range, fast, and reliable. But CQC is somewhat obtuse. It's mostly mouse clicks and dialog boxes to configure it, but its vibe isn't super intuitive. -Tom

CQC = Charmed Quark Controller. Used to be pay, but is now free. It's a little like Home Assistant in its versatility, but only runs on Windows. It handles IR, serial, and IP inputs. You train it by repeating the input several times, and link the input to an action, which can be just about anything. There's an ISY driver, too, and I realized after posting that I use the driver rather than REST for ISY control for one of these routes, or both; I forget. But it's complicated. That's part of the "took me forever" story. Happy to help if you want to try it, though. -Tom

I'm using URC Complete Control RF remotes to MSC-400 base station to CQC (over RS232) to REST commands for some of my remote control of the ISY, and URC Total Control RF remotes to MRX-20 base station to REST commands for some other control. Took me forever to figure out how to program it all, but it's nice to be able to do anything, from anywhere, with a hard-button remote. -Tom

Sorry, I mean battery powered. -Tom

I bought one of the wired ones but never installed it. Since I need 4 total, and only one location is prewired, I didn't bother. I'm still unclear from all these posts. Is there a compatible wireless model still available? -Tom

What model are you using? Mine reached end of life, too, but I couldn't find any that are compatible with the SmokeBridge. -Tom

Deleting with sudo appears to have worked. Thanks. -Tom

Thanks. I've attached a screencap of the directory. There's a debug.log dated the last day listed in my post above, and a debug1.log dated the first day listed above. Then there are debug-*date*-.log.gz files for several days up to today, and a debug-*date*-log file for today, which seems to conform to your description above. Should I rm debug.log and debug1.log? p.s. I have PG3, too. Where are its log files stored? -Tom

Can no one help me? I'm sure all II need to do is log in and delete a file somewhere, but I need some guidance as to which file. -Tom

My PG2 log has entries in it from 5Jan2021 to 10Apr2021. Nothing newer than that. Can someone tell me how to reset it so I can start getting new entries again? -Tom

I agree about the location. I looked for an appropriate location but couldn't find one. Please suggest one, and thanks for trying to get it to work. -Tom

I got my RA2 switch, and I added it to the Lutron app. It's working. I'm having trouble adding it to your Ra2 Select NS. I think I'm putting in the right information - integration ID is 2, and device type is 11. But when I click the "Save Changes" button, it just stays in the pushed state, and no more nodes show up - the number of nodes stays at 1. Can you get me unstuck? -Tom

That was it! Thanks! -Tom

I can't seem to add a device to Google Home. I have it (a LampLinc) set up in the portal, with a spoken. In Google Home, I follow the instructions to add a new device, and choose "Works with Google." This page already displays my other linked service (Lutron). Then I search for "Univ" and the Universal Devices entry shows up. I choose it, and the portal login dialog appears. I log in, and it says "Universal Devices is linked" at the bottom, then that screen goes away and the Home home screen displays, but there is no new device shown. If I repeat the process, when I choose "Works with Google", it still shows Lutron as a connected service, but not Universal Devices. So I guess it hasn't worked, even though I get that "Universal Devices is linked" message. I have two ISYs in the portal, if that's relevant. Also, this device is on an ISY on PolIsy, version 5.3.0. I'm not sure how it would know which one to link to, or if it's supposed to link to both. Anyway, I'd appreciate any help you can give me. -Tom

I just installed it yesterday, when I powered up my new main repeater. And I don't have any devices yet, so I can't really use it. But I will have at least one soon. Because of the timing, I was one of those who answered the poll with Inventory only. Would you like me to respond again? Also, you've seen how many people have been mentioning RA2 or Caseta in the "Insteon is dead" threads. I think the prospect of future demand is good. -Tom

How about your RA2 Select NS? I just got a repeater and installed your PG2 NS. -Tom

From the manual. I don't speak z-wave, so I don't understand it. -Tom

I am fooling around again with a very old Monster IWC600 z-wave scene controller on my Vera, and the behavior is similar. It has 4 buttons, and they have mutually exclusively lit LEDs. The idea is that there is always a scene selected. Maybe that's what they were going for with the Zen32. To turn something off with the Monster controller you have to make a direct association with the button. If you do, the second press will turn off the associated light. The second press of any button also reports a button 0 push for each of the 4 buttons meaning, I guess, that the scene hasn't changed. Or something. -Tom

Except for whatever capabilities/features UDI decides not to include in ISY on Polisy, and for which no simple and/or complete alternative exists. That's why we're discussing Elk now. Also, wouldn't this be the ideal solution to the "multi ISY/one interface" scenario asked for by those individuals who automate more than one property (assuming they can set up a VPN or secure port forwarding)? I'm in that boat now, on a long-term remote work assignment. An ISY NS would also support multiple Polisys at multiple locations now, and after the 994i is completely dead. UDI ought to care about that. I'd be OK with someone in the crowd creating the NS I seek. UDI certainly has demonstrated that they'll work with NS authors to get them whatever they need. -Tom

Thanks. I'm aware it could be done this way, but I was really hoping to hear that support for a 994i would either be built in to ISY on Polisy, or that someone would create a NS. Easy for me to say, but it shouldn't be very hard or risky, since the protocol is well known, and completely under UDI's control, as opposed to many other devices you might attempt to add to Polisy. And such a NS would ease the transition to Polisy for those who want to add control but not disrupt anything in place. In fact, I'd argue that UDI should write and maintain such a NS themselves. -Tom

How does ISY on Polisy interact with a 994i? That's the question. If I want to migrate everything over to Polisy, but leave Elk lighting running on a 994i, how could I interact with it? -Tom