We would need to see the scene setup. The issue with the "old" method was button "A" and load "1" where always grouped together. While this worked if button "A" was the linked to load "1" in "Flags" it broke if the load was changed to another button.

It could have been that the links were incorrect, due to the "bug" in before the fix which was causing issues.

In any case it sounds like it is working now?

1 hour ago, Javi said:

We would need to see the scene setup. The issue with the "old" method was button "A" and load "1" where always grouped together. While this worked if button "A" was the linked to load "1" in "Flags" it broke if the load was changed to another button.

It could have been that the links were incorrect, due to the "bug" in before the fix which was causing issues.

In any case it sounds like it is working now?

I just noticed we have moved on to page 2 and didn't your post. Look at the previous post which I changed to state what I believe is the issue, at least on my computer (Windows 10 using Firefox). I also cleaned up the post before that, since so much of that was trying to figure out the problem.

I have both new i3 keypads working as intended.

Thanks for hanging in there with me.

Edited yesterday at 04:36 PM1 day by nowandthen

@Javi Sorry for the delay in responding, but I’ve done some more testing and am still seeing some unexpected behavior with the I3 keypads. 

Here's the basics ... I have two I3 4-Button keypads that work in tandem to control two loads and several scenes together.  Here is how the switches and associated scenes are set up:  

Keypad 1 (MBath Lights New) setup is:

•  Button A (LOAD):

  • MBath Lights New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

  • Upstairs Lights (Responder)

• Button B:  

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button C:  

  • MBath Combo New (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button D: 

  • MBath Fan New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

Keypad 2 (MBath Fan New) setup is:

• Button A

  • MBath Lights New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

  • Upstairs Lights (Responder)

• Button B:  

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button C:  

  • MBR Closet (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • Upstairs lights (Responder)

• Button D (LOAD): 

  • MBath Fan New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

Scenes:

• MBath Lights New

  • MBath Lights New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New A (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New A (Ctrl/Rsp)

• MBath Fan New

  • MBath Fan New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New D (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New D (Ctrl/Rsp)

• MBath Towel Warmer

  • MBath Fan New B (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New B (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Controller)

  • Shelly 1 Mini (Responder)

• MBath Combo New

  • MBath Combo New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New A (Responder)

  • MBath Fan D (Responder)

  • MBath Lights New A Responder

  • MBath Lights New C (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights (Responder)

 

Here’s the odd thing I am seeing:

When I turn on/off button D on Keypad 1 (MBath Lights New), it should turn the fan scene on/off, but it also turns the LED for button B (towel warmer) on/off.  It doesn’t change the actual scene that turns the towel warmer load on/off – it just affects the LED on that button.

If I turn on/off button D on Keypad 2 (MBath Fan New), it should also turn the fan on/off, and it does, but it does not affect the LED for button B on Keypad 1.

As far as I can tell, I don’t have anything configured for an interaction between Keypad 1 buttons B and D, but the system does show some kind of interaction there.

BTW, I previously deleted these two keypads and associated scenes, and recreated them from scratch to go through the re-enrollment process for I3 devices on eisy (per the wiki).  Also, checking the device Configuration --> Show Device Links Table for both switches shows all links as “Identical” when I Compare them with what’s in the eisy.

I’m sure this is probably challenging to follow but let me know how I can best help if further info or logs would be helpful.   

17 hours ago, dwengrovitz said:

@Javi Sorry for the delay in responding, but I’ve done some more testing and am still seeing some unexpected behavior with the I3 keypads. 

Here's the basics ... I have two I3 4-Button keypads that work in tandem to control two loads and several scenes together.  Here is how the switches and associated scenes are set up:  

Keypad 1 (MBath Lights New) setup is:

•  Button A (LOAD):

  • MBath Lights New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

  • Upstairs Lights (Responder)

• Button B:  

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button C:  

  • MBath Combo New (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button D: 

  • MBath Fan New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

Keypad 2 (MBath Fan New) setup is:

• Button A

  • MBath Lights New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

  • Upstairs Lights (Responder)

• Button B:  

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Ctrl/Rsp)

• Button C:  

  • MBR Closet (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • Upstairs lights (Responder)

• Button D (LOAD): 

  • MBath Fan New (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Combo New (Responder)

Scenes:

• MBath Lights New

  • MBath Lights New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New A (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New A (Ctrl/Rsp)

• MBath Fan New

  • MBath Fan New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New D (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New D (Ctrl/Rsp)

• MBath Towel Warmer

  • MBath Fan New B (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights New B (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Towel Warmer (Controller)

  • Shelly 1 Mini (Responder)

• MBath Combo New

  • MBath Combo New (Controller)

  • MBath Fan New A (Responder)

  • MBath Fan D (Responder)

  • MBath Lights New A Responder

  • MBath Lights New C (Ctrl/Rsp)

  • MBath Lights (Responder)

 

Here’s the odd thing I am seeing:

When I turn on/off button D on Keypad 1 (MBath Lights New), it should turn the fan scene on/off, but it also turns the LED for button B (towel warmer) on/off.  It doesn’t change the actual scene that turns the towel warmer load on/off – it just affects the LED on that button.

If I turn on/off button D on Keypad 2 (MBath Fan New), it should also turn the fan on/off, and it does, but it does not affect the LED for button B on Keypad 1.

As far as I can tell, I don’t have anything configured for an interaction between Keypad 1 buttons B and D, but the system does show some kind of interaction there.

BTW, I previously deleted these two keypads and associated scenes, and recreated them from scratch to go through the re-enrollment process for I3 devices on eisy (per the wiki).  Also, checking the device Configuration --> Show Device Links Table for both switches shows all links as “Identical” when I Compare them with what’s in the eisy.

I’m sure this is probably challenging to follow but let me know how I can best help if further info or logs would be helpful.   

Before attempting to debug any issues, if these were created prior to the lates update the scenes may have been created with the wrong mappings. Try write updates. I think this works but I only have 2 i3 Keypads, and pervious scenes were wiped during testing. So I am not 100% sure write updates works, it may required deleting and recreating the scene.