Everything posted by Teken
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
Sounds like Fred Flinstone ~ Yaba Daba Doo!!
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
Its not only signal strength its the improper placement of the internal antenna. If someone grabbed a brain and moved the antenna so its behind the front (plastic) cover plate the signal propagation and distance would increase. Just that simple move costs nothing but a change in the assembly process. Smartlabs has done this to several products already but sadly haven't moved forward on all the rest. As for the use of filters no matter what HA a person uses filters will always be needed in varying degrees. This comes down to what kind of electronics and loads they have in place. I've personally never had to deploy any filter in my home and that isn't because of luck. It came down to taking the time to test, validate, and deploy hardware that didn't suck / emit noise in my home. I can safely state 99% of the population have never taken the time, effort, or expense to do the same. In the ideal world none of this should be required but we don't live in the mythical world of ideal. We live in a world where producing the cheapest product as fast as possible to make X margins. As I have stated many times in this forum and others the average person really doesn't have many options when it comes to HA. Series folks use a hardwired solution that doesn't run on the power lines or use RF. Because of this all of the current iterations of protocols: Insteon, Z-Wave, ZigBee, X-10, WiFi, BLE will forever be hobbled and limited. As noted up above integrating a dual protocol like WiFi AC and (name your flavor) will increase the reliability and flexibility to integrate with X vs Y. Right now manufactures have their head on backwards . . . They believe using cloud hosted services and new *Standards* such as Apple Home Kit, Weave, Thread, name what ever make belief system out there is the magic bullet. It isn't . . . These are all band aids and stop gaps such as IFTTT / Stringify
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
LOL ~ That's a lot of filters you got there mwester!!! RE: Reliability can be improved upon by increasing signal strength. Nobody in the HA space is coming even close to FCC limit, none. This is why Gen 5 devices are able to offer better performance because they have increased the signal strength so has Insteon. They all still fall short of the limit set by the FCC though . . .
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
Z-Wave / ZigBee is very much like X-10 . . . One only needs to ask all of the Z-Wave folks who have 9999999999999999 siren / repeaters all over their homes!!!
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
I'll preface in saying (which most people know who have read my past replies) that Smartlabs needs to do better in almost every possible area: - On board new 3rd party hardware vendors - Support existing 3rd party vendors with clear, concise, and detailed API documentation - Use the highest quality components in all hardware - Actually use the Alpha / Beta program to make the product(s) better and for God's sake reply to freaking questions posed!!! - Return the EDOC's to the public domain as they were in the past - Build upon the strengths of the power line / RF Insteon protocol by increasing the signal output - Engage the general public to obtain critical feedback about the ups and downs of the product(s) - Get rid of the off shore sales and support ~ They truly suck ~ As they hurt sales !! - Continue the development of i3cs and integrate the latest encryption standards - Fully utilize the cloud as its intended and not the [censored]ized version you and the rest of the world use now - Incorporate energy monitoring / energy management into all of the products - Incorporate environmental monitoring while supporting analog sensor arrays Having said all of the above I've come to know first hand you should never count Smartlabs out. Consider this single company has been able to endure the onslaught of Z-Wave, ZigBee, WiFi, BLE, for the last five years. They have consistently released or updated one new Insteon product each year since coming to market. No other home automation player can say the same . . . Bar none Insteon offers the sexiest, modern, and pleasing hardware product in this space. Aeotec is a close second while the rest simply look and feel like X-10 junk from the dollar store. With the advent of Joe Dadda leaving (Thank God) this new VC has the opportunity to push Insteon further into the market place. How?? First, by releasing every NA hardware device to EU, Asia, Eastern countries. Its only been five freaking years and the stupid idiots that ran the show failed to tap into the other 5 billion humans chomping at the bit to purchase said hardware!!! After this has been done push forward to redesign the 2413S PLM so its not a 2 year ticking bomb. Better yet how about you (Ya you ~ New Guy) start selling the PLM chip to UDI so they can push sales even further into EU, Asia, Eastern countries by the sales of ISY Series Controllers. Now . . . Some have coined this as the VHS vs Beta wars . . . There is no war ~ That ship has sailed long ago due to the lack of vision, common sense, and greed. The only people who are going to take on *Insteon* are smaller companies who see value in their wares. Larger companies with true vision have already decided to adopt a hybrid environment where supporting a multi protocol only makes sense. I dare say the first company who offers WiFi as the base protocol and includes a combination of Z-Wave / ZigBee will have the best longevity in the HA Space. This assumes their product has the same look and feel of Insteon. Many don't and every quarter there is *Yet Another* Z-Wave startup that has failed and went bankrupt. This is why if there were to be a *Next Generation* protocol Smartlabs should integrate WiFi AC into all next gen hardware. Doing so is so obvious it just makes me cry. A HA network that can support both protocols takes advantage of all the strengths such topology brings. In closing, I still believe Smartlabs / Insteon has a fighting chance to taking market share. But, only if they follow the listed ideas posed above.
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
LOL [emoji23]
-
Can Insteon be secure and backwards compatible?
Backwards Compatibility, yes . . . But, older hardware would not have the newer security features. This has been seen in the evolution of the Insteon protocol of i1, i2, i2cs. i3cs has been in the works for ages and there is no view in sight as to when it will be released.
-
Boot-Time Notification?
The program I listed up above does that already. ☝️[emoji106] Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Smoke Bridge Duplicated Alerts
First thing is to have matching firmware and UI. Next, based on your feedback there seems there is another program firing off a email. You can confirm this via the level 3 logs. As a quick test increase the wait to ten seconds this will eliminate any chance this is a debounce error. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Boot-Time Notification?
The easiest method is to change the time interval from minutes to seconds. That same value would be saved as a Integer and then relayed to you via email. The only downside in going this route is (IF) you have lots of other programs this very short (second) counting may tie the ISY Series Controller up. Also keep in mind the ISY Series Controller would of course need to be placed on a UPS to keep counting. This program your reading about is to track when the controller has been rebooted. It's not intended to track when there is a power loss in the home for that you would need something else to monitor and track. If you need a Insteon solution let me know . . .
-
Smoke Bridge Duplicated Alerts
Assuming you have only one active email program in place. Insert a 3 second wait in the then section prior to the email path entry and report back success vs failure. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Insteon New Motion Sensor 2844-222 2nd Gen
Having dealt with two of their *latest* Developers who just so happens to be off shore. [emoji849] They / He is a fail!!! [emoji35] If I ever hear another soul utter the words: Do the needful! I'll crawl through that telephone line and crush them! ☝️ Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
New PLM. Now ISY-994 won't control scenes
No worries, please do remember to make a back up once you're done. Fire a copy to a USB drive / stick ~ The other to a cloud hosted storage service for off site storage and safe keeping. Rock On . . .
-
Insteon New Motion Sensor 2844-222 2nd Gen
LOL . . . I through a rant out and you come back with calm, cool, and collected!!! Great steal my fire and roll with it ~ I love it. Regardless, on many points I do agree and not to broad brush everyone who does work in Smartlabs. There were a few really great folks who offered great insight, help, and follow up support. What I can say is the 3rd party *Off Shore* technical support is a utter fail. Dealing with East Indians for more than 35 years in the tech support role from Dell, Microsoft, Cisco, the list is endless. Has always be a disaster and this falls squarely on Managements insistence of pushing down costs. 3rd world nations that have a feeble grasp of the English language is a fail. Their technical prowess is even less than fail but results in endless call backs, poor customer satisfaction, and loss of future sales for the parent company. Having personally worked, trained, and forced to coach these $0.05 employee's is waste of oxygen. Anyways, back on point: I would very much like to see the latest motion sensor have 100% support in all aspects which includes the 16 options stated in the API!!!
-
New PLM. Now ISY-994 won't control scenes
I would offer your personal experience relays when all recommended steps are completed but don't yield the positive results one expects. The end result is a hard reset is the final solution . . .
-
Insteon New Motion Sensor 2844-222 2nd Gen
The last official 4.6.X firmware is said to support the most basic feature of this sensor. The 5.XX branch also offers basic support but many of the other features are not. One year is fast approaching since this product was launched and this device and others are still poorly implemented. How the general public is supposed to have faith and confidence in dipping their toes into the whole home automation space with hardware that is so lack luster in support and developmentation. Having dealt with four Smartlabs, so called developers in the past the phrase useless comes to mind. If the API documentation does not offer the insight to yield a end result. That is a failure of the company who released said document to the general public. If the hardware does not do as the API states it should ~ Again, that is a failure on the mark of the company who made said hardware. I'll never understand how it is Insteon / Z-Wave is so hard to implement when the so called API is supposed to be clear, concise, and to the point. The reality is none of this is the case because manufactures can implement some, part, or all of the Z-Wave protocol as has been seen countless times in random products! With Insteon I am at a loss as to explain why it is basic features can't be provided. Are people reinventing the freaking wheel here?!?!? Its only been a year since the new motion sensor has been released . . . Which leads to the final question: This new motion sensor is supposed to support 16 other features. When are these features going to be provided and supported??? 1,3, 10 years??? I've posed the same question to the Beta team with the various team leads over the course of a year. There has been zero response to any of these basic queries!!! That makes the entire Alpha / Beta program useless, waste of time, and pointless. This new VC guy who purchased Smartlabs needs to fire the lot of them and start from scratch.
-
New PLM. Now ISY-994 won't control scenes
Anytime you update the firmware on the controller you must *Manually* download the appropriate Admin Console. This information is boldly listed in the steps to follow. There are several things that need to be done in order as listed out by the other forum members. - Remove power from the ISY Series Controller. - Apply power to the 2413S PLM for at least ten seconds. - Apply power to the ISY Series Controller. - Complete the PLM restore which can take hours to complete. If that process is completed in mere seconds / minutes ~ Its failed. - If the above has failed you need to complete a ISY Restore. Once complete you can perform the PLM Restore process. - Additional steps may to complete a hardware restore of each device. If you have a large Insteon network this can take a lot of time. - If none of this works and based on your previous replies its just easier to start from scratch as you did in creating new scenes. The cost vs value ratio comes down to how much time, patience, and hair on your head . . .
-
Using ISY 99i without PLM
Going off memory I don't recall the last 3.XX firmware having the ability to use the controller without a PLM. I believe this was introduced mid way in the 4.XX branch and also carried over to the 5.XX I also recall you'll need to use one of the newer 4.XX Admin UI's as it will throw an error at some point during launch. I would submit a technical support request with UDI so they can offer you all the correct resources to get it up and running. Great little Controller for sure!! Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Bad PLM?
You're still covered submit a RMA with Smarthome. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Bad PLM?
On the PLM is the LED bright or dim? Do you see network traffic on the PLM's LED when you activate any switches / sensors? If you perform a link table compare what numeric link count is presented? When performing this test the house must be quiet and no one moving around and complete at least 3~4 link counts to obtain a good average. If you have 50 Insteon devices in the home and the link table count reports back something crazy stupid like 12 that may be an indicator. If simply unplugging the 2413S PLM restores service its more than likely a failing unit. I would first check to see if yours is still under the two year manufactures warranty. If not you can purchase a new one or try your hand in the PLM repair guide in this forum. You can always try a hell merry and do a PLM restore to see what happens. But historically this is a band aid which buys you time . . . All of the above assumes you don't have any other noise induced issues in the home . . .
-
Nothing showing in "current state" after Leak detector install
If you reboot the controller the state is lost until that battery device is activated. You can see the current state for the leak sensor by pressing the set button. Once the heart beat comes in (approx 24 hours) it will show up too.
-
Monitor water softener regeneration
Greg, Would love to see the final product once you get it all hammered out.
-
Monitor water softener regeneration
Hello Greg, Wire is cheap and can be had almost anywhere hence why I made that initial suggestion. If you find the two wire method doesn't offer the results you need you can always purchase a very cheap (sub $5.00) float and attach the same to the I/O ports of the Open-Close sensor. I always try to come in with the cheapest solution first and build up from there. When cheap doesn't work just throw money at it I say!!
-
Monitor water softener regeneration
Hello Greg, I'm going to assume your looking for a Insteon solution? If so, the easiest solution is to use a Insteon *Open / Close* (Trigger Linc) sensor via its external I/O ports. Simply use a two conductor wire and insert the wire pair into the tank at the defined level you believe is the best. Right now Smarthome has their 20% off sale and if you don't care about a two year warranty you can purchase a refurbished open / close sensor before the 20% discount for $19.99: http://www.smarthome.com/refurbished-insteon-2843-222r-wireless-open-close-sensor.html A new sensor with the 2 year warranty is $34.99 before the 20% discount: http://www.smarthome.com/insteon-2843-222-wireless-open-close-sensor.html Just a simple option ~ Let us know what you end up going with.
-
In-Line Water Leak Detector
Hello Deirwin, Short answer is: Yes Long answer is: I believe there are several factors to take into consideration when thinking about any new system. For the record and clarity I am a little biased since the Water Hero system is in place and being used in my home. You will need to keep that in mind when you review my thoughts and replies for the following: Goals: You will really need to define the long term goal(s) and your requirements. Many will go into something and under / over purchase just because someone else did so. But could never accomplish the very same either because they didn't have the technical skills or the finances to do so. Always plan ahead and have a system that matches your skill set and can be expanded further is my thought. Budget: It goes with out saying finances are key but people should not get caught up spending too little vs too much. For me I consider the total *Value* each product brings to me and what it can do on a practical manner. If you've Googled long enough you're more than aware the prices for similar devices range from $25.XX ~ 1200.00 from simple (Insteon) leak sensors to commercial multi point sensing units. Only you can determine if the item in question will offer that value for your intended purpose. Having been using and testing for the Water Hero team for more than three years. The current *sensing* portion has been incredible for me in every way. I've included a few screen captures from my system and what can be seen and how its portrayed. Please note, the charting and graphing comes from my Brultech Green Eye Monitor (GEM) and Dash Box (DB). The primary goal for me was finding a none invasive system that was easy to install and set up with out the need to replace the main water meter or hire a plumber. The other requirement was a system that would integrate well with the Brultech GEM / DB system which it does. Next, was having the ability to interface and use the ISY Series Controller which it does. The other requirement was having a open API that could integrate with most systems on the market. The team is in the process of documenting and releasing this open API for the system. They are also working hard on releasing a smart application which can offer remote control and basic water metrics. I've been pushing very hard on the team to ensure the system is as open and can operate in a local and stand alone mode vs cloud only. I am not a fan of cloud based services or products and thus my bias toward local first vs cloud first has been the main driver when working with the Water Hero team. I have been very fortunate in the fact we have a good working relationship with the founder and CEO. Because of this, the company has taken on dozens of my suggestions and requirements I believe offer the best value, performance, and integration. The team and I are on the last portion of Beta testing for no less than 100 field testers. The development team is hard at work in the Alpha trials to release a smart application which supports iOS / Android. As of this writing I have been hard at work on expanding my home automation system to support reactive and proactive voice alerts / announcements via Amazon Echo, and Julie U.S. Many elements of this depends upon the tight integration of the ISY Series Controller which tracks the current, low, high water flows in my home. At a high level the system will be able to inform me of *Water Signatures* which I can proactively track, monitor, or intercede to. Other aspects I have been field trialing is multi point alert notifications which relay the information to a person in a common sense manner. That has been from simple LED board indicators to relay volume, active, minimum vs maximum values met. To graphing from Water Hero, Dash Box, IFTTT, Google Charts, to SEG. For me this Water Hero system serves many facets which are: Global Water Consumption, Security, Water Control, Water Conservation, and being able to share the data with other people. The most important aspect I can not over state is the system is extremely accurate. It does not rely on systems that use paddles, infrasonic, mythical guessing software, or hall effect / LED counters. The system uses tried and true none contact / none invasive magnetic detection right at the water meter. If the dial on your homes water meter moves - It tracks it! There is no track every 10, 20 gallons per blah blah blah. It tracks when ever the water meter dial moves and spins around. So what does that mean in plain English? Its taking measurements from a *Certified* device installed by the city!! Let me know if that answers your questions and whether you need more feedback.